Hearing about a promotion opportunity at work is exciting and nerve-wracking. As an internal candidate, you’ve got the insider knowledge to speak the hiring manager’s language and prove you’re the right fit for the position.
But even then, you might feel nervous about giving a bad interview — especially if you feel like your future at the company is on the line.
Take the time to reflect on your experience with the company and start practicing your answers to promotion interview questions. Thinking ahead can help you feel more at ease to present your best self and earn that position.
How to prepare for a promotion interview
Internal candidates have quite a few advantages for a recruiter or hiring manager when compared to new hires. They reduce recruitment costs, don’t require extensive employee onboarding, and already fit into the company culture.
You might already stand out against external candidates, but it’ll take extra effort if your coworkers are vying for the same promotion. Here are six ways to prepare before the interview:
1. Consider whether you’re the best person for the job
Employees who are passed over for a promotion feel less committed and motivated and might stop putting in the effort at work, but keep in mind that the decision might be outside of your control.
Carefully read the job description and your company’s promotion policy to understand whether you have the right skills and experience. Think about your performance and current position compared to other applicants, even if they’re your teammates.
The prospect of internal promotion is exciting, and it’s disappointing not to get one. But it’s okay if it goes to someone else. Coworkers might have more seniority or a different background that better suits the promotion, and that isn’t a reflection of your worth. It just means this wasn’t the right time for you to transition.
2. Give your manager a heads-up
Your promotion will shuffle roles and responsibilities in your department, which could give team members a heavier workload while they look for your replacement. Letting your manager know you’re applying is good practice, especially if you’ll be moving off the team in your new role.
Your director supervisor is usually involved in the interview process and might need to sign off on the move. They should hear it from you rather than through gossip in the workplace so they can properly prepare and support you in your application.
Use this conversation as an opportunity to ask for honest feedback about your job performance, strengths, and weaknesses. Your manager may also be able to give you interview tips or insights about what hiring managers see in the best candidates.
3. Reflect on your company milestones
Make a list of all the times you’ve excelled in your current role, including projects you’ve worked on and their results, noteworthy accomplishments, and recognitions from management. Any data that supports what you’ve contributed to the company is worth including.
For every time you step up, describe the initial situation, your problem-solving strategy, and the results. Preparing specific metrics will show your value and tell the interviewer or hiring manager why you deserve the promotion.
4. Highlight your transferable skills and knowledge
Imagine your current role as a stepping stone to the new position. What transferable skills, experiences, and knowledge have you built in your current job? Don’t just focus on your concrete experiences and hard skills.
Soft skills also give you a competitive edge, like organization, critical thinking, and communication skills.
5. Prepare your weaknesses
The hiring manager might speak with your current or previous supervisors and examine performance reviews. Be prepared to recognize your biggest challenges and discuss the measures you’re taking to learn and improve your skills.
6. Study the company
One obvious advantage that internal candidates have over external job seekers is an insider’s view of the company’s core values, mission, and goals. Find ways to align your career aspirations and work ethic with those company values. It’ll show that you’re enthusiastic and engaged with the organization.
Top job promotion interview questions and answers
Hiring managers might skip past general questions about your experience and education to more detailed ones about your current role and future career aspirations. Here are a few common job promotion interview questions and sample answers to practice:
1. What do you enjoy about your current role?
What are hiring managers really asking? Employers want to know your feelings about the organization and company culture, as well as how your skill set matches your current expectations. Highlight positive experiences and the ways the organization has supported you along the way.
Sample answer: I really enjoy the work dynamic of my team. My manager gives us the autonomy to develop our projects, but I feel supported every step of the way. Everyone shows up to help when necessary and does great teamwork to push the department’s goals forward.
2. Why do you want to be promoted?
What are hiring managers really asking? They want to know how your career goals align with the company’s goals. The hiring manager needs to understand what motivates you, how you set goals, and where the new promotion fits into your future career aspirations.
They want you to tell them reasons to promote you rather than keep you in your same role.
Sample answer: In the last few years, I set out to improve my efficiency and effectiveness in my current role. I know that I’ve gained all the tools to problem-solve, perform at a high level, and respond to challenges in this position.
It’s time to push myself to undertake the next challenge, continue my learning, and become a bigger asset to the company.
3. Why are you the best candidate for this promotion?
What are hiring managers really asking? The hiring manager wants to know you have the confidence and drive to succeed in a challenging new role. This is your opportunity to present your current accomplishments and milestones.
Sample answer: Throughout my time at the company, I’ve always been proactive about pushing myself forward. I’m results-driven and have delivered above expectations almost every time.
Together with my manager, I’ve helped improve efficiencies and increase profit goals by 15%. I’ve also repeatedly proven that I’m willing to lend a helping hand to my coworkers when needed. I’m excited to bring that same energy to this role.
4. What do you know about the role you’re applying for?
What are hiring managers really asking? They want to understand your engagement and enthusiasm for the new role. Demonstrating your interview preparation and research shows the hiring manager that you’re proactive and see a task through from start to finish.
Sample answer: I understand that this is a leadership position, and I’ll oversee the department's operational efficiency. I also know that it involves working with other department leaders rather than on an isolated team. I’m eager to lead the department, and I’m already very familiar with everyone’s strengths and weaknesses and how to push them to improve.
I’m currently working with a coach to prepare to step into the role as a leader, both by strengthening my soft skills and learning how to form stronger relationships with team members.
5. If you don’t get the promotion, what are your next steps?
What are hiring managers really asking? They want to know how you respond to unforeseen setbacks, disappointments, and constructive feedback. It should be an opportunity for career growth, not the seeds of resentment. Reassure them that you’ll continue doing your job if you don’t get the promotion.
Sample answer: Although I’ll obviously be disappointed, I’m thankful for the opportunity to interview. This process has been a chance for me to think critically about my job performance and strengths and weaknesses.
If you don’t choose me for the role, I’ll request feedback to understand how to improve myself for the next opportunity.
6. If you get the promotion, what do you expect to achieve?
What are hiring managers really asking? Hiring managers want to understand your problem-solving process and critical thinking skills. Use the STAR method to tell a story: define the challenges you’ve faced, outline the process, and describe successful results.
Sample answer: One of this year’s company goals is to increase efficiencies across departments. If I’m chosen for the promotion, the first thing I would do is audit our communications and workflow with other departments to pinpoint redundancies and break down silos.
I'll share the results with other managers and leadership and work together to improve communication.
7. Tell me about a time you addressed an unforeseen complication at this company
Why are hiring managers really asking? “Tell me about a time” questions aim to understand how you approach specific situations and how you think critically under pressure. As an internal candidate, you should use an example from your current job and show off your problem-solving skills.
Sample answer: Our department unexpectedly lost two team members, which was a big weight on the team. Initially, everyone was stressed about hitting deadlines. I proposed a meeting between the whole team.
We analyzed all of our projects, prioritized and reassigned tasks, and built a new production schedule for the following few months. We also scheduled regular check-ins three times a week to stay on task.
It was a fast-paced environment for a while, but we met all our deadlines and became a stronger team.
Tips to excel in an internal interview
The hiring process is nerve-wracking for anyone, even if you're already a part of the company. Here are a few extra tips for interviewing for a promotion:
-
Make your resume stand out: Ensure your resume is up-to-date with your current job role. Likewise, edit the resume’s language to include the required skills and experience for the new position.
-
Prepare your answers: Taking the time to practice answers for situational questions or behavioral questions will help you answer confidently rather than pausing to find the right words.
-
Follow up with questions: Brainstorming your own questions to ask in a promotion interview shows enthusiasm, proactiveness, and confidence. Here are a few questions to consider asking:
-What skills does the ideal candidate for this position possess?
-What are the biggest obstacles of the job?
-What goals would you like me to meet in the first few months?
-How does this position fit into the company's goals?
- Show your know-how: Use company-specific language to demonstrate your engagement and commitment. If possible, insert the company’s core values into your responses.
-
Go the extra mile: Although you should always be on your best behavior, the weeks leading up to the interview process are a time to prove you’re the best candidate to get promoted. Go above and beyond to demonstrate your value as an employee.
-
Send a thank you email after an internal interview: A follow-up after the interview shows gratitude for the hiring manager’s time. Keep it short and sweet. Ask if they need additional info and say “thank you.” The small gesture shows your enthusiasm and thoughtfulness.
Moving on up
A promotion is an incredible opportunity to advance to the next stage of your career. It’s a healthy sign that there are accessible growth opportunities within the company, so even if you don’t get promoted this time, there’s still space in the future.
You’ve put in the work, and the hiring manager has noticed. A little extra practice with promotion interview questions will help you feel more confident in your answers, put your best foot forward, and show you have what it takes to get to move up the ladder.
